Sometimes I feel like Amazon is my second home! I’m always on there looking for something. Recently, I published a post on the Top 10 Highest Rated Anti-aging Products on Amazon and it’s a really popular post. So I thought it would be fun to find out what Amazon Makeup products women are buying! One of my favorite things about Amazon are the Reviews. Seeing thousands of people weigh in on the pros and cons of a product means you get the good, the bad and the ugly before deciding to purchase. The other great part is knowing which products are SO good they’ve made it on to Amazon’s Best Seller list. I went through the best seller list for Makeup and sorted out the the highest rated Makeup products on the list.
Let’s see if we can find some favorites here or perhaps a new goodie to try! Shipping on all of the products on the list is FREE if you are an Amazon Prime Member. By the way, if you are not an Amazon Prime Member, what are you waiting for? It’s so awesome! You can sign up for a 30 day Trial on Amazon Prime Here.
Ready for the reveal? Here are the Top 10 Amazon Makeup Bestsellers with at least 1000 4 to 5 Star Reviews!
Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette
This Nude eyeshadow palette contains 16 highly pigmented eye shadows in a creamy, waterproof formula. There are three color choices available including Nude Matte (shown above), Nude Exposed (which looks strikingly similar to a very famous Naked palette from Urban Decay) and Nude Naturel. The formula is 100% vegan and cruelty-free.
The Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette gets an astounding 4 1/2 stars from over 6500 women who say the shadows blend easily, have a great color payout and are just as good as eyeshadow palettes from Sephora. At this price, what have we got to lose?
Price: $9.97 – $13.95 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 1/2 Stars 6,589 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Coty Airspun Loose Setting Powder
Coty Airspun is an oldie but goodie. It’s been around since 1935 and is still beloved today. This loose face and setting powder helps to minimizes the appearance of fine lines, wrinkles, acne, bumps, scars & other blemishes, giving your facial skin a smoother, softer look. YouTube Superstar, Tati Westbrook swears by this stuff and over 5600 women on Amazon agree with her. Amazon offers a great deal on a two pack of this powder which will last forever!
Price: 2 pack – $11.94 USD 1 pack – $5.97 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 Stars 5,683 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Kabuki Makeup Brush Set by Lamora
This Kabuki Makeup Brush Set by Lamora is a 10 piece Collection with synthetic bristles. Included in the set: ✓ Flat Kabuki ✓ Round Kabuki ✓ Angled Kabuki ✓ Flat Angled Kabuki ✓ Tapered Kabuki ✓ Precision Tapered ✓ Precision Flat ✓ Precision Round ✓ Precision Angled ✓ Precision Flat Angled. The brushes are vegan and cruelty-free.
The majority of reviewers on Amazon agree that the makeup brushes are soft, do not shed and are easy to clean. With over 12,000 4 1/2 star Reviews, this is a NO-Brainer! This set of Amazon Makeup Brushes come in Pink (shown above) or Rose (a lighter, baby pink). They also have a Six Piece Essentials Set and a Contour Set available.
Price: Kabuki Set – $24.95-$26.95 USD, Essentials Set – $14.95 USD, Contour Set – $14.95 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 1/2 Stars 12,122 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Pronexa Hairgenics Lavish Lash – Eyelash Growth Enhancer & Brow Serum
Lavish Lash is a botanical serum with Biotin & natural growth Peptides that promises drastic increases in length and thickness of your eyelashes and eyebrows in as little as 60 days. Over 15,000 women on Amazon have given this serum 4 1/2 stars and swear this stuff really does work. And there are before & after pictures to prove it. I don’t know about you but I’m ordering this one ASAP!
Price: $29.99 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 1/2 Stars 15,494 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer
In my opinion, this is the best concealer at the drugstore. Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer delivers a smooth, flawless coverage that does not settle into fine lines or wrinkles. It’s great for under the eyes or spot concealing and does a good job on dark circles. This concealer is available in 12 shades. There is also a brightening formula and neutralizing formula available. With over 6300 4 Star Reviews, this is the highest rated and best selling concealer on Amazon! If you haven’t tried this, you’re missing out on one of the best drugstore beauty finds of all time!
Price: $12.78 USD for Two, $6.39 USD for One
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 Stars 6,335 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Milani Baked Blush
This Blush from Milani is richly pigmented, highly buildable and comes in 11 beautiful matte and shimmery shades. This powder blush features a mélange infusion of colors baked on Italian terracotta tiles. I have tried this is a few shades and really liked them (Luminoso & Dolce Pink are both beautiful). It’s a close dupe to MAC Cosmetics Mineralize Blush at a fraction of the price.
Price: $6.33 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 1/2 Stars 2,339 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
NYX Matte Finish Setting Spray
For a matte makeup look that stays put, NYX Matte Finish Setting Spray reduces shine and keeps your makeup looking good all day. NYX Cosmetics offers vegan products and they are certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand. At just under $7.00, this setting spray is a steal according to over 5400 women on Amazon who have given it 4 1/2 stars.
Price: $6.89 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 1/2 Stars 5,472 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
This liquid eye liner from Stila has a marker like tip and offers precise application that glides on with ease. The formula dries quickly and won’t smudge or run. It is available with the original marker like tip or an alternate “micro” tip and it comes in 9 shades. Amazon reviewers rave about the easy application and lasting power of this liner and have given it 4 stars!
Price: $22.00 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime
Rating: 4 Stars, 5521 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
Thank Me Later Face Primer
This matte face primer is said to extend the wear of your makeup keeping it flawless all day. Thank Me Later Face Primer is a waterproof formula that keeps you shine free, minimizes the appearance of pores and fills in fine lines/wrinkles for a smooth makeup application. This primer is vegan and cruelty-free and the brand behind it, Elizabeth Mott, offers a 100% Satisfaction or your Money Back Guarantee. At just $15.00 for 1.6 oz., this one is going on my list! This Primer is also available in an Illuminating formula and there is an Eye Shadow Primer as well.
Price: $15.00 USD Face Primer, $13.06 USD Eye Primer
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 4 1/2 Stars, 3,414 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
WUNDER2 Wunderbrow Long Lasting Eyebrow Gel
Wunderbrow is an eyebrow gel infused with ‘Hair-Like’ Fibers to Fill & Sculpt the brows. The company claims it is completely waterproof, smudge proof, transfer proof and lasts up to 3 days. The formula is available in five shade selections and is vegan and cruelty-free. This product is just short of 4 stars (3.8) with a total of an unbelievable 13,414 Reviews! Women warn that it takes some practice to get the application down but once you do, you’ll have nearly perfect brows! Sounds like a winner to me!
Price: $22.00 USD
Free Shipping with Amazon Prime.
Rating: 3.8 Stars, 13,414 Reviews
BUY IT HERE
So there you have it, the Top 10 Highest Rated Amazon Makeup Best Sellers! I found a few from the list that I’m going to try. How about you? Have you tried any of these products? What caught your eye? As always, I would love to hear from you. Please leave a comment below!
Until next time…
Follow me on Instagram, @Susie_Truett_, for updates and all of the latest from 40andholding Beauty Blog!
This post contains Affiliate Links. This means if you buy something using one of these links, I make a small commission off of the purchase. This helps me to be able to buy more makeup & skincare products to review on the Blog. And it helps cover the costs associated with maintaining 40andholding. If you do use my links, I appreciate it and send you hugs and a big thank you!
SHOP ALL OF THE TOP 10 AMAZON MAKEUP BEST SELLERS ON MY
AMAZON STOREFRONT HERE.
If you enjoyed this article and found it helpful, please give it a like and share with your friends on Facebook, Twitter or Pinterest! Use the buttons below to share!
What a fabulous group of makeup products Susie. It never ceases to amaze me how many great products you can get on Amazon!
Thank you Phyllis! They have everything, right? Even groceries and houses! We never need to leave the house! 😂
Hi Susie! I have to confess that it never occurred to me to look for my cosmetics on Amazon (I think my biggest association with them is books, books, and more books, along with some general household items 😉). You’ve definitely opened my eyes here! I’m especially intrigued by the lash thickening serum, as I think it’s something I could use. And I can attest to the effectiveness of the Maybelline concealer … I’ve been using it for a few months now and it really works. Thanks for sharing all these possibilities!
It’s amazing the range of products that Amazon has! I am curious about the lash serum too! When you have over 15,000 women agree that something is great, there’s got to be something to it!👍 Thank you for reading!💕💕
What an interesting article, not heard of some of the items as they aren’t available from amazon UK. Love Milani blushes.
The Milani blushes are so good for the price, right? Thank you for stopping by & reading!💕💕
Apart from 2 products the others didn’t know them and most probably I wouldn’t have considered them if I hadn’t read your blog post!
I’m happy to have given you some options you may not have thought about!💕💕 Thank you so much for reading!
Thanks for sharing this with us, I appreciate the most of the items are very affordable and accessible via Amazon.
I’m happy to have found a few new gems for us to try! Thank you so much for stopping by & reading!💕💕
These products seems amazing!
I’m excited to try a few of them! Thanks for stopping by & reading.💕💕
As someone that is far too lazy to leave my house to shop (thanks, Amazon and Shipt!), this is super helpful!
Lol, right? Amazon makes it easy! Thank you for stopping by & reading.💕💕
Great compilation of beauty products. Use amazon for so many things, but never makeup. What great prices you’ve discovered with excellent reviews. That’s one of my fave things about amazon, are the reviews. Thanks Susie!
xo Melanie
You’re welcome Mel! I’m excited to try a few of theses makeup finds. I love the Reviews too! Thank you for stopping by & reading!💕💕
So many great products. Thanks for sharing.
You’re very welcome. Thank you for stopping by & reading!💕💕
Wow, it’s incredible the amount of different products that Amazon has to offer. That lash serum too must be a great one!
Right? We literally never have to leave the house to shop! 😂 Thank you for stopping by & reading!💕💕
I don’t buy things from amazon without reading the reviews. This is so helpful. Thanks for gathering all the best makeup products in 1 post.
You’re welcome! Thank you so much for stopping by & reading!💕💕